News

News

Friday
July, 1
More

    Plant Liberation?

    MELBOURNE – “Every day, thousands of innocent plants are killed by vegetarians. Help end the violence. Eat meat.” These words, written last month by an Edinburgh butcher on a blackboard outside his shop and shared on a vegan Facebook group, led to a heated online discussion. Some condemned the butcher for seeking to blur an important line between beings capable of suffering and those that are not. Others took it as a joke, as the butcher said he had intended it. But jokes can make serious points.

    “How do you know that plants can’t feel pain?” I was often asked when I stopped eating meat. In 1975, in the first edition of Animal Liberation, I offered two distinct responses. First, I argued, we have three strong reasons for believing that many nonhuman animals, especially vertebrates, can feel pain: they have nervous systems similar to our own; when subjected to stimuli that cause pain to us, they react in ways similar to how we react when in pain; and a capacity to feel pain confers an obvious evolutionary advantage on beings able to move away from the source of the pain. None of these reasons applies to plants, I claimed, so the belief that they can feel pain is unjustified.

    My second response was that if plants could feel pain, even if they were as sensitive to it as animals, it would still be better to eat plants. The inefficiency of meat production means that by eating it we would be responsible not only for the suffering of the animals bred and raised for that purpose but also for that of the vastly larger number of plants they eat.

    To continue reading, register now.

    As a registered user, you can enjoy more PS content every month – for free.

    Register

    or

    Subscribe now for unlimited access to everything PS has to offer.

    %post_title%

    Last Mile Source

    Find us on

    Latest articles

    - Advertisement - spot_imgspot_img

    Related articles

    Plans for bigger defense budget get boost after bill...

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...

    Commander Craig: 007 star made honorary Royal Navy officer

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...

    House passes $1 billion for Iron Dome system in...

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...

    5 missing after Navy helicopter crashes into sea off...

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...

    Afghan allies who applied for special visas still in...

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...

    New Taliban head of security for Kabul is wanted...

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...