News

News

Wednesday
May, 25
More

    COVID Goes to Court

    CAMBRIDGE – The coronavirus is everywhere: in the air, on surfaces, in our respiratory tracts, and, over the past week, at the US Supreme Court. On January 10, key elements of US President Joe Biden’s controversial “vaccine-or-test” mandate provisionally went into force, requiring that all workers at companies with more than 100 employees be vaccinated or tested regularly for COVID-19. With roughly 84 million Americans affected by the mandate, all eyes were on the Supreme Court, which on January 13 struck down the measure.

    With the support of a massive body of scientific evidence, the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) argued in favor of the mandate, emphasizing that workers “face a grave danger … in the workplace.” But the National Federation of Independent Businesses and 27 states (all Republican-controlled) contended that the vaccine is an “invasive, irrevocable, forced medical procedure” that should not be imposed en masse.

    Although the technical question before the Court was whether OSHA has legitimate authority to enforce the mandate, the justices also considered whether COVID-19 does indeed pose a threat distinctive to the workplace. Yet, with only 62% of Americans vaccinated, the stakes were – and are – much bigger than these questions imply. At issue is whether the 38% of Americans who refuse to get the vaccine should be permitted to imperil the majority’s ability to earn a livelihood without facing unnecessary risks to their safety. And even this broader framing still doesn’t address the risks imposed by the unvaccinated on health-care workers, parents, separated families, patients in need of non-COVID-related treatments, and all the children whose development has been disrupted or derailed.

    We hope you’re enjoying Project Syndicate.

    To continue reading and receive unfettered access to all content, subscribe now.

    Subscribe

    or

    Unlock additional commentaries for FREE by registering.

    Register

    %post_title%

    Last Mile Source

    Find us on

    Latest articles

    - Advertisement - spot_imgspot_img

    Related articles

    Plans for bigger defense budget get boost after bill...

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...

    Commander Craig: 007 star made honorary Royal Navy officer

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...

    House passes $1 billion for Iron Dome system in...

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...

    5 missing after Navy helicopter crashes into sea off...

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...

    Afghan allies who applied for special visas still in...

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...

    New Taliban head of security for Kabul is wanted...

    BOSTON — Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker announced Tuesday he will activate up to 500 members of the...